Buying Rebuilt-Title Auto Insurance: What You Need To Know in 2025

If you need auto insurance for a car with a rebuilt title, you are in luck. There are plenty of insurance companies that will cover your vehicle. But you may have difficulty finding coverage if you are looking for more than a liability car insurance policy.

Most companies are comfortable meeting the state’s minimum requirements for auto insurance coverage for rebuilt titles. But a full coverage policy that includes collision and comprehensive coverage is more of a risk for a car that was totaled or salvaged.

What is the best insurance company for a car with a rebuilt title?

Many different companies may be willing to insure your rebuilt vehicle. Depending on where you live, you may have an overwhelming number of options available for car insurance. 

As long as your car has passed all the necessary tests to have a rebuilt title, you will likely be able to compare multiple companies and quotes to find one that will suit your needs. 

The table below shows a list of companies that insure rebuilt title cars.

Rebuilt title car insurance is not difficult to find. Most of the companies listed above would be willing to insure your vehicle, especially if you have a decent driving record.

For example, does Allstate insure rebuilt titles? Yes, but the company is likely to only offer liability policies to individuals who drive rebuilt cars. On the other hand, Geico is one company that often provides full coverage policies after a proper vehicle inspection. 

Read more: National General Auto Insurance Review

What is the best type of insurance for cars with rebuilt titles?

If you are trying to decide what type of auto insurance to purchase for your rebuilt title, you may want to speak to insurance companies to see your options.

While you typically want to consider purchasing a full coverage auto insurance policy on your vehicle, rebuilt titles can be tricky regarding specific car insurance coverage types. Many insurance companies are willing to cover a rebuilt title with a liability policy but will not offer a full coverage policy or other options such as roadside assistance.

You can shop online and compare coverage options and insurance quotes simultaneously. For example, if you’re looking for a full coverage policy on your rebuilt title, researching online will help you learn which companies are more likely to have what you need.

How much is auto insurance for a rebuilt title?

Car insurance rates vary for several reasons. Some of the most common factors that impact auto insurance rates include:

• Age
• Gender
• Car make and model
• Driving history
• Credit score
• Marital status 
• Occupation

If your auto insurance rates vary with a rebuilt title, the above factors likely influenced your rates. The table below shows average auto insurance rates for vehicles with a rebuilt title. While full coverage is not always an option for rebuilt titles, the table compares the average monthly cost for liability and full coverage.

Average Full Coverage and Liability-Only Coverage Monthly Car Insurance Rates for Rebuilt Titles

As you can see, Geico and USAA offer the best rates on insurance, but USAA is only an option for current and former members of the military and their family members.

Are there insurance companies that don’t cover rebuilt titles?

You may come across certain companies that are not willing to offer you car insurance coverage for your rebuilt title. Some of these companies include:

• Direct General
• Travelers
• Liberty Mutual

Most states have rules concerning rebuilt titles, and vehicles undergo a rigorous review before they can go from totaled or salvaged to rebuilt. (For more information, read our “Buying Salvage-Title Auto Insurance: What You Need To Know“)

You may find that certain insurance companies require that you provide information on your vehicle, a notice from your department of motor vehicles that your vehicle has passed inspections, and paperwork from a mechanic stating your vehicle is safe to drive. 

What are the advantages and disadvantages of purchasing a car with a rebuilt title?

If you are considering purchasing a car with a rebuilt title but have not done so, you may want to think through the pros and cons. 

Some of the advantages to owning a car with a rebuilt title include:

• You can purchase the vehicle for significantly less than the same make and model with a clean title.
• Insurance on the vehicle is likely to be less expensive.
• You may find vintage or classic cars still fit for the road.

However, some disadvantages of owning a car with a rebuilt title include:

• It may be more likely to break down.
• Some insurance companies may refuse to offer you coverage.
• The manufacturer’s warranty is likely to be no longer active. 
• There may be issues you’re unaware of because of previous damage.

Buying a car with a rebuilt title can be a great way to save money, but you want to be sure your vehicle will stand the test of time and not break down right after you buy it.

Many people who are considering buying a car with a rebuilt title should take the vehicle to a trusted mechanic to have them inspect the vehicle. Doing this will help you avoid certain cars that may be more likely to give you issues in the future. 

Car Insurance for Rebuilt Titles: The Bottom Line

If you own a car with a rebuilt title or are considering buying one, you need a car insurance policy.

Most companies are happy to cover rebuilt titles with a liability-only policy. Suppose you are looking for a full coverage policy or for coverage options that exceed your state’s minimum requirements. You may have a difficult time finding a company willing to insure your rebuilt title.

You can shop online and compare coverage options and quotes for your rebuilt title. However, don’t settle for the first company that makes an offer. You want to ensure you don’t pay too much, so look over your options first. 

Instead, research and compare companies to find an option that works best for you and offers you the coverage you want. If you’ve not purchased a car with a rebuilt title but are considering it, consider the pros and cons of owning a rebuilt title car before making any final decisions.